logoalt Hacker News

Google stole open source code without crediting the authors (Artemis/Minitap)

87 pointsby MysteryPancaketoday at 2:39 AM17 commentsview on HN

Comments

dataflowtoday at 3:26 AM

> The author history was harder to understand. An earlier package file listed Pierre-Louis Favreau, Jean-Pierre Lo, and Nicolas Dehandschoewercker. The version that replaced it removed all three names and substituted another author. The only change to the files was the author list. GitHub’s activity record shows that the replacement happened through a force push in August, before our investigation this September.

Wow, this looks pretty damning. I can't imagine Google seeing this as worth the risks. Is an innocent explanation possible here?

show 3 replies
neilvtoday at 3:58 AM

Regardless of whether or not Google is liable, what would be interesting to me is how this happened, the role(s) at Google that were involved, when each knew of the problem, and what each did.

harshavamsitoday at 3:34 AM

https://github.com/google/artemis/commit/371aa6df56880643da5...

They're trying to cover it up now

show 3 replies
pmkarytoday at 3:24 AM

When you say "don't be evil"; just where is your threshold Google?

show 2 replies
bilekastoday at 3:46 AM

Well I am shocked, who would have thought, an advertising company who prides themselves on not being evil, used code that wasn't credited. I mean, if that's the case, we better start a revolution.

de6u99ertoday at 3:35 AM

I'd like to know how many imposters work in big tech.

RossBencinatoday at 3:54 AM

Flagging because the title here on HN is editorializing. The actual page title is "I expected better from Google"

I was going to comment on the title's perpetuation of big IPs stealing/theft meme but it turns out that TFA did not use those words.