logoalt Hacker News

esafakyesterday at 6:49 PM3 repliesview on HN

This makes no sense. The hardware is only going to get cheaper. In a decade, everybody could be running an ASI on their phones.

What we need to do is to make unaligned AIs illegal and monitor for them, like we do with nuclear weapons. And make aligned AI strong enough to counter it, for deterrence and defense.


Replies

xg15yesterday at 7:26 PM

> The hardware is only going to get cheaper.

Is that so? Last time I checked, RAM was getting a lot more expensive...

show 2 replies
politicianyesterday at 7:02 PM

I downvoted you because I think the OPs model is far simpler to implement and suffers from fewer conflicts of interest.

If we go down the regulation of alignment route, we'll have to ask experts to create those regulations and monitoring regimes. And which experts will the government ask? Oh, right, the parties that stand to benefit the most from regulation: OpenAI and Anthropic!

When "the experts" make certification cost $100M/model because "safety and alignment", then they will have cemented their duopoly.

Meanwhile, tariff rates on compute is a simple percentage that can be scaled up and down. Congress doesn't need experts to do that. Vendors can participate proportionally to their scale. This is far simpler and far more fair.

show 2 replies
visargayesterday at 6:57 PM

Yes, and we need to make microprocessors that do good work, not hack others. /s

show 1 reply