logoalt Hacker News

bcantrillyesterday at 11:30 PM5 repliesview on HN

Saying that we don't need to fear human extinction in the next ten years (or even the next hundred?) does not feel like an extraordinary claim?


Replies

0xDEAFBEADyesterday at 11:43 PM

No one knows what is going to happen. But a lot of species have been going extinct lately.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FDd58a4WQAAWaXh.jpg

mortenjorckyesterday at 11:44 PM

The students in the computer lab had no guarantee that they wouldn't, say, download a copy of Napster infected with the CIH virus later. The fact that they were not under imminent threat from some kind of Hollywood-style network worm did not mean they were immune from more realistic attack vectors.

Likewise, one can quite reasonably say there is no credible existential, Hollywood-style threat from AI in the foreseeable future while recognizing far lower-stakes, yet important risks that need to be addressed.

jacobgoldyesterday at 11:47 PM

If you think AI will be powerful enough to change the world in huge ways, then it does seem reasonable to assume some level of risk of destroying the world too.

Stating that the probability is zero when we simply don't know what the probabilities are does seem like an extraordinary claim.

Imagine how reassuring it would be to people if we had evidence that there's no existential risk?

thin_carapaceyesterday at 11:42 PM

the earth has been 1 decision away from explosion for nearly a hundred years now. do you anticipate a change to this agenda very soon? personally I imagine the same trajectory continuing.

show 1 reply
abletonliveyesterday at 11:47 PM

No it does not seem like an extraordinary claim, unless this is your first time hearing such claims. For the rest of us, we've heard this every decade and it turns out to be entirely untrue.

Nuclear, Overpopulation, Peak Oil, Y2K Bug, Global Warming.

No, we aren't going extinct in the next 10 years.