logoalt Hacker News

lolakuttytoday at 4:59 PM3 repliesview on HN

>quickly identify a contradiction or a counterargument and state it confidently.

How does this make this a "contrarian position"? At least I don't understand the negative connotation. To me this makes this "contrarian" at least a bit smarter than the one parroting the popular opinion...


Replies

LPisGoodtoday at 5:03 PM

The smarter thing to do would be to steelman the original position and not assume that the weakest of counterarguments — stated confidently and without much further analysis — sufficiently refute it.

debo_today at 5:02 PM

I like this notion of being contrarian in what it means to be contrarian.

show 1 reply
porkshoetoday at 5:24 PM

[dead]