logoalt Hacker News

fzn7today at 8:50 PM1 replyview on HN

Your reply is pure, distilled whataboutism.


Replies

ericmaytoday at 9:21 PM

The premise of the OP is whataboutism.

But you can take a step back and ask, well, what's the guiding framework here?

Is it arbitrarily picking certain time periods to make a point? Why do we go back to "Japan" and World War II when Japan started the war and was massacring and colonizing people throughout east Asia?

Why wasn't Germany mentioned in the body count? Dresden is a popular one that comes to mind.

Why do we only focus on lives lost? Maybe America saved 10,000,000 Chinese from Japanese occupation so on balance we're saving lives?

show 1 reply