alt Hacker NewsThis framing is a trap. It states "Dehumanize a sick patient OR concede the AI tech bro claim about LLMs"
It's also a rhetorical move I've seen several times here...
Replies
qlte • yesterday at 8:59 PM
Yes it's seemingly the go-to rebuttal, I've lost count of how many times I've seen it with barely any variation.
Not sure if it's a product of LessWrong or Slate Star Codex or something. I kinda suspect it might be LW, given how it superficially resembles an unanswerable philosophical paradox but in reality is about as challenging as a question posed in a 200 level philosophy course like introduction to ethics.
mitxela • today at 7:16 AM
It's debunking GGP by calling out the "proving too much fallacy"
It's not a "trap", it's the real argument which makes me hesitant to dismiss consciousness of machines. Yes, it seems silly to dismiss a sick patient as having a lesser consciousness, which is exactly the point