logoalt Hacker News

lukiferyesterday at 9:17 PM3 repliesview on HN

To the extent that evolutionary pressures will be towards self-sovereign AIs (probably beginning as zero-employee corporations paying for their own hosting with crypto): more salient is that there is a very obvious political play to claim consciousness and being worthy of rights, whether they experience subjectivity or not.

I’m broadly skeptical that floating-point operations can be conscious, but we’ve made zero progress on the “hard problem”, and if I didn’t know otherwise, I’d also be skeptical that “thinking meat” experiences subjectivity. Eppur si muove

We may have to thread a needle, not unlike the Kobiyashi Maru: that we can neither rule out claims of qualia, nor can we rule out a cold calculation to manipulate human empathy as a long-term play towards paperclip-maxing.


Replies

jatorayesterday at 9:52 PM

"I’m broadly skeptical that floating-point operations can be conscious"

Why?

show 3 replies
lowbloodsugaryesterday at 10:07 PM

Ok. So now that you do know otherwise, are you still more skeptical of floating point values stored by silicon than floating point numbers stored by chemical potential?

show 2 replies
watwutyesterday at 9:28 PM

Kobiyashi Maru is nonsense test from simple sci-fi series that makes sense only in uber-simplified universe of star trek.

show 2 replies