logoalt Hacker News

Arainachyesterday at 9:58 PM3 repliesview on HN

Everything is political. If you think it's not, you're just benefiting from the status quo and blind to it.

Even ignoring that history loves to repeat itself, plenty of politics in all forms of media has aged excellently, and plenty of politics that haven't aged well are still insightful into the period of the piece.


Replies

mrobtoday at 10:49 AM

>Everything is political.

"Everything is political" is the classic motte-and-bailey fallacy beloved by the most obnoxious politics pushers. The fact that it's impossible to remove all traces of politics from fiction does not excuse subjugating art to ideology. When people complain about "political" works they're complaining about works where the author appears to care more about how you vote than the story.

norometoday at 9:21 AM

everything may have a relevance to politics, but there is a line between art and propaganda.

krigetoday at 5:25 AM

There's a striking difference between telling and tone deaf preaching and when people complain about politics they always, without fail, mean the latter.

The stance of "everything is political" itself is extremely tone deaf.

show 1 reply