logoalt Hacker News

vegadwyesterday at 2:54 PM6 repliesview on HN

This feels self-selective to how some people work, because it requires using MCP to contribute.

I'm a reasonably heavy AI user, and have some custom skills/MCP servers I'd share, but there is no way in hell I'm connecting to some arbitrary MCP server and connecting my Github account to it. Noppppeeeee.


Replies

xnxyesterday at 3:09 PM

Agree. I was going to type in my setup, but no way I'm touching the instructions on https://mysetup.ai/connect. Also I don't use Codex, Claude, or Pi.

show 3 replies
steveybrownyesterday at 4:21 PM

Fair point, MCP contribution was always optional, although not obvious. I've updated it to make manual contributions outside of MCP more prominent

show 1 reply
taudetoday at 1:33 AM

I use almost zero MCP servers. I do vibe a bunch of custom CLI tools with minimal access to do the things that support my workflows. Been happily integrating with all-the-things, while my companies MCP server connectivity changes daily based on security posture and firewall configs, etc....

show 1 reply
Retr0idyesterday at 5:00 PM

Maybe I'm missing out, but I've never used a single MCP, ever.

show 1 reply
abyssknightyesterday at 4:59 PM

I stopped reading after "Ask them on X", but contribution by MCP just compounds on the issue.

rubylimeteatoday at 12:19 AM

[dead]