logoalt Hacker News

vidarhtoday at 4:01 PM1 replyview on HN

Your second sentence does not support the claim in your first sentence; it's merely a second unsupported claim. It is also entirely irrelevant to the argument.

The threshold for behaviour consistent with having emotions (note: not behaviour sufficient to prove emotions) was one I purposefully set extremely low, because your comparison to a disk drive is so ludicrous, and yet your disc drive will still not clear it.

Do you have an actual argument?


Replies

chrisjjtoday at 5:07 PM

My disc drive, like your LLM, has persistent memory, does not have emotions.

If your LLM "shows behaviour consistent with having emotions" beyond my disc drive delivering a PDF of poetry, let us please see the evidence.