logoalt Hacker News

orangecatyesterday at 2:31 PM3 repliesview on HN

they realize that meant a real human artist probably didn't get paid to make it so society is worse off

This is a form of the broken window fallacy. Society is not worse off when production requires less labor, any more than it's worse off when someone uses an open source library rather than paying someone to reimplement it.


Replies

Chance-Deviceyesterday at 2:53 PM

> This is a form of the broken window fallacy.

I’m not sure I see it, can you elaborate?

show 1 reply
bluefirebrandyesterday at 2:47 PM

> Society is not worse off when production requires less labor

Society is definitely worse off when people who exchange their labor for capital have no opportunities to do so

johnnyanmacyesterday at 9:28 PM

>Society is not worse off when production requires less labor,

Not objectively in every situation. But that does seem to be the case and objective here.