logoalt Hacker News

Roxxiktoday at 2:35 AM0 repliesview on HN

I mean this is what MoE is the first step of. Slice your intelligence to make it more efficient without losing much capability.

CUA seems to disaggregate. Train specialist models and make delegation explicit. But I think the future for capable but efficient models involves doing it all in one package. I have no idea how that architecture would look like or how to train it.

Like a human would, I can walk and talk, without thinking hard about walking and still not stumbling. Specialized sub-circuits that interact. Not via a text protocol, but by directly interacting.

Did you see the Astra plays Portal 2 videos? You can see how separate viewing a scene, understanding the scene and acting in the scene still are. And in this model of interaction, a very capable model still makes stupid mistakes.

It is remarkable, that it works at all. But it is neither effective nor efficient. And in my opinion the real revolution comes not by capability, but by integration.

So to tie the loop: I think CUA makes an interesting first step towards specialization, but I am not sure if that is the logical conclusion of how AI should work.