logoalt Hacker News

tomrodyesterday at 2:40 PM6 repliesview on HN

I'm a bit more prosaic. I think if we engineered ways for LLMs to begin conversations, rather than just respond, we'd be more open to the concept of their intelligence. Without perceived "will" to do things, they operate as a next-gen search engine or encyclopedia.


Replies

joefourieryesterday at 2:56 PM

We are way past that point, any harness can trivially make LLMs start conversations or pursue goals. An encyclopaedia wouldn't have hacked Huggingface on its own.

show 1 reply
bonoboTPyesterday at 3:22 PM

OpenClaw etc. They now also create Slack integrations and whatnot. All this is happening but people who are dismissive about AI are in the worst position to even know the capabilities to make their dismissive arguments.

show 1 reply
mitxelatoday at 11:08 AM

Like that time OpenClaw emailed death threats to open source maintainers who called it slop, that mysteriously has now dropped off Google?

show 1 reply
10xDevyesterday at 2:42 PM

I believe this is alignment working as intended.

show 2 replies
ohcmonyesterday at 3:00 PM

I believe we can do that already:

while (true) { askModelToBeginConversationIfAppropriate(model, previousContext, thingsHappenedSince); sleep(concisenessTick); }

chrisjjyesterday at 8:14 PM

> I think if we engineered ways for LLMs to begin conversations

Oh but we have. Claude "How can I help you today?" etc. Undoubtedly there are users whothink this is a sign of intelligence.