logoalt Hacker News

unsungNoveltyyesterday at 2:51 AM6 repliesview on HN

Snowden has repeatedly talked about why he wouldn't return to US cos the trial won't be fair. He wanted to be able to talk. But due to his role, the trial would be a muppet one where he can't even talk. Or am I wrong?

At the time, look at the situation of Chelsea Manning, Julian Assange and the many whistle blowers before Snowden? How can u blame him?

Edit: Am unable to reply to comments. HN don't let you comment 2-3 levels in or is it moderation? - Fixed.


Replies

slgyesterday at 3:02 AM

Manning and Assange are both free today. Isn't that proof that whether it was reasonable to believe Snowden was correct at the time, history has proved him wrong?

show 4 replies
judge2020yesterday at 3:27 AM

With the right/same lawyer, could've potentially worked out similarly to Kiriakou, who only had a few years behind bars and later became a celebrity due to his interviews.

show 1 reply
nlyesterday at 2:56 AM

The OP was right - avoiding a unfair trial is still fleeing.

The word "flee" is not a pejorative in any way. For example flee North Korea all the time.

show 1 reply
Arodexyesterday at 7:40 AM

Is Snowden able to talk freely in Russia?

show 1 reply
sandblastyesterday at 3:27 PM

*Bradley Manning

firesteelrainyesterday at 2:59 AM

The problem is he can’t excuse the offense under the Espionage Act because it doesn’t have a public interest defense. One could argue that it should have that defense. But that doesn’t mean the resulting trial would have been a “muppet trial”

He could have had counsel, challenged the government, and had a jury decide guilt. It would have been fair. It actually looks worse to flee like he did

show 2 replies