logoalt Hacker News

lern_too_spelyesterday at 6:57 PM0 repliesview on HN

> To move it to another program, classified and unreported, under which it could hide again. Don't be naive.

Why? They first made a more limited program to comply with the law and then shut that down because the data wasn't useful. If they made another program exactly like the original, the SSCI would shut it down, or a whistleblower would point out a program that they know to be clearly illegal, whereas the original program was arguably legal, with the government's justification in the leaks. After the ruling, the government would not be able to provide justification for obtaining that data from the telcos with their old legal argument because it is invalidated by precedent.