logoalt Hacker News

Aboutplantstoday at 8:09 PM2 repliesview on HN

For better or worse it won’t be long until we get private exploration for minerals and water on the Moon and nearby planets, at a relatively decent scale (in comparative terms)


Replies

Rover222today at 10:08 PM

Please explain the "worse" part. Should we be in a moral panic about lifeless barren chunks of rock being put to some use?

mrguyoramatoday at 9:25 PM

What could possibly fund the private exploration of minerals or water on the Moon or planets?

Which of the 180ish elements would possibly be found on a foreign body in enough scale that couldn't possibly be found, made, or replaced by cheaper means here on earth?

Space mining doesn't make sense! We can't even justify exploiting all known resources here on earth itself because they aren't profitable, how do you work those numbers when, instead of literal slave labor, you have to pay the energy cost of going up and then back down for every kilo of matter?

If it's often not worth it to mine literal gold here on earth because it can't be profitably extracted, the core limit on gold mines as an investment and business venture, why would it be profitable to, for example, mine that gold on Mars and try to bring it home?