logoalt Hacker News

Coeurtoday at 11:24 AM6 repliesview on HN

Author claims the system setting "Privacy & Security > Apple Intelligence Report > Report Duration" with its 3 options [Off | 15 minutes | 7 days] sends that data to Apple with that frequency. This is wrong - this is a transparency report so that you as a user can see everything that is getting sent to Apple as a part of Apple Intelligence. Nothing additionally is getting sent to apple if you switch this away from "Off".

It's placed right next to a similar report for the user to see which apps generally connect to the internet and to which domains.

Basically, the main point of the article, "I discovered that macOS 15.3 had enabled a feature that was phoning home every 15 minutes with personal data" is not true.


Replies

makeitdoubletoday at 2:46 PM

The main point of the article is not the report duration toggle, it was the whole activation of Siri and Apple Intelligence.

The author turned it off in a previous version, and as they updated their OS it got turned on again (the "Apple said yes" part of the title)

hosteurtoday at 1:34 PM

IF this is true apple has done a horrible job at explaining what this is.

iAMkenoughtoday at 2:16 PM

Worth noting that this “report” can only be viewed through a json data export file, which the average Apple user has no idea how to interpret.

It is designed to not be user-friendly.

> Nothing additionally is getting sent to apple if you switch this away from "Off".

Another way of saying this is “personal data is still being sent to Apple if you switch this to off.”

show 1 reply
devindotcomtoday at 7:09 PM

that's not the main point of the article

that's not even the topic of the article

that refers to a post from 2025 that he links to. this is clear from the first sentence of the article. I suspect maybe you didn't actually read the article and spent more time writing this erroneous comment than you might have reading the article.

StilesCrisistoday at 1:39 PM

Disappointing that we have multiple 10-deep reply chains pearl-clutching Apple's disrespect for the user, and no one actually bothered to verify the premise of the article. They just want to be mad.

show 2 replies