logoalt Hacker News

malfistyesterday at 3:08 PM13 repliesview on HN

What are you going to do? Switch to android which has even more ads?

What we need is antitrust enforcement so there are other options and more competition. The free market can't fix anything if the market is just a race to the bottom between two companies


Replies

TheDongyesterday at 3:26 PM

> Switch to android which has even more ads?

Android has more ads if you buy it through a carrier, but you can easily make it have far fewer ads by installing LineageOS, and then installing Firefox with the real uBlock origin (not ublock origin lite).

iOS does not allow you to install alternative browsers, nor can you customize the OS to the level of lineageOS, so iOS simply cannot match the best that you can do on android.

Android has more of a free market because on my pixel phone, I can choose either Google's android distribution, or LineageOS, or Graphene, or build my own ROM. I can use F-Droid or the google play store.

What we need is laws requiring that all iDevices apple makes are open hardware which support installing android, iOS, or a custom OS you build yourself, all hardware-essential drivers are free, and so on. That would let people compete on the software side of thing while Apple's hardware team iterates on that. If iOS really is better on its merits, people would install it even with the option to pick other OSs.

show 3 replies
wredcollyesterday at 4:34 PM

What ads does android have? I see ads when I'm inside specific apps, youtube, chrome, etc, but not when I'm using apps that don't have ads?

kyriakosyesterday at 3:22 PM

I am either blind to ads or i see no ads in android (samsung). of course many apps have ads, at least not in the actual OS.

show 1 reply
curt15yesterday at 3:38 PM

At least Android allows truly alternative web browsers with ad blockers that aren't handicapped by Manifestv3 limitations.

show 1 reply
adrian_byesterday at 5:46 PM

Android by itself does not have any ads.

I have had until now 4 Android smartphones, which did not have any ads whatsoever.

Like other posters have said, if you do not buy the phone directly, but subsidized by some carrier, then it might come with crap installed on it.

Of course, currently Google appears to make efforts to make Android worse, so it would not be surprising if ads would appear.

show 1 reply
animuchanyesterday at 4:03 PM

Android user here, switched from iOS (not because of ads, a different gripe).

Not going to lie, it's a holistically bad experience, very similar to iOS in this regard. But Android doesn't show ads. The closest thing would be the Google Photos pestering to back up to cloud, things like that. It's per app, and usually there are better apps to replace the offending ones. (And vendor garbage can even be uninstalled, although it's very deliberately inconvenient to do.)

Bonus points for having Brave browser with built-in adblock, for the free YouTube Premium-ish ad-free experience.

show 2 replies
graemepyesterday at 3:18 PM

I do not see a lot of ads on Android but i think that might be my particular (light and limited) usage.

You are right though. A duopoly is rarely a competitive market, especially for complex products (it can be for commodities)

show 1 reply
palatayesterday at 9:35 PM

> Switch to android which has even more ads?

I am on Android, I have no ads.

PontifexMinimusyesterday at 9:15 PM

> Switch to android which has even more ads?

I never see ads on my android phone

coldpieyesterday at 3:36 PM

I had an iPhone 13 Mini. I found it to be much worse about ads.

Every time I opened the system settings, it would insert an ad for an Apple TV Trial after a 2 second delay, causing all the items to shift down, forcing me to either wait every time I opened Settings or else mis-click when it finished loading the ad.

Android doesn't do this, it just shows me the system settings. I was so glad to go back to Android.

cyberaxyesterday at 5:40 PM

My stock Pixel phone has zero ads. It prompts you to enable things like Wallet and all the AI stuff, but I just turned that off, and it's not bothering me anymore. There are no persitent ads.

worikyesterday at 7:28 PM

> Switch to android which has even more ads?

I use Android

No ads.

I feel left out, thank Dog for that!