logoalt Hacker News

altcognitotoday at 3:29 PM1 replyview on HN

I don't see it fundamentally any different than knowing when to use a tool. Is this tool like RAG an important enough corner case to train for it? I dunno.

LLMs already shell out and write code to solve certain problems. This is just a special case of that.


Replies

andy12_today at 3:40 PM

It's a special case for an LLM, and you can use an LLM with structure output to get similar results, but you can engineer specifically for that case to get better results per dollar for it. That's why there is little reason to adapt GPT 5.6 Sol or wathever for this task; it can already do it (at a high cost). For OpenAI to compete with Jev they have to maintain another line of models, something like "GPT-5.6-instant-decision", that is small, fast and cheap, in the scale of GPT-5 nano.

Note that I don't think OpenAI is incapable of doing it, but I just don't think they will bother with it.

show 1 reply