logoalt Hacker News

redox99today at 6:22 PM2 repliesview on HN

Same. In fact I found 6 Astra to be a downgrade in situations where I didn't need the extra intelligence.


Replies

Rapzidtoday at 7:21 PM

Yeah, I use Astra for destroying vaguely scoped asks and tasks, and then for high-level design and plan generations..

Otherwise I'm using 5.6 Sol for actual plan execution and review..

cmrdporcupinetoday at 6:31 PM

Yeah.

Astra was/is superior for planning type tasks. It was capable of doing seemingly magic things with rather vague/lazy instructions ("I need to be able to test this on Windows, maybe a qemu VM or something? Shrug." ... 1 hour later "yeah i built you a whole qemu + eval windows image + harness of powershell scripts + shell scripts to retrieve & verify harness.").

And for UI work -- which is not something I do a lot of but do here and there -- it was clearly superior to 5.6 Sol.

But it also feels sloppier? Somehow. And too expensive to use.

We'll see how Sol 6 is.

show 2 replies