logoalt Hacker News

joshstrangetoday at 6:53 PM2 repliesview on HN

Maybe it's due to 20x / 5x != 4 but I have the $200/mo Claude and $100/mo Codex and I get _way_ less usage on Codex, well under 1/4th the usage. In 1-2 days of semi-heavy _single_ agent usage with Sol High I can burn through my whole week of Codex. Again, this is not running multiple agents, just 1 at a time.

Compare that to Claude and I can run multiple agents on Opus almost indefinitely. YMMV of course but I was shocked at how quickly I burned through Codex usage.

On the context window, I feel so cramped on Codex, compacting happening every time I turn around is annoying. I didn't realize how much I enjoyed the Claude context window size.


Replies

rgbrennertoday at 7:02 PM

Same experience. Have both subs. It's just not true anymore that Codex gives you more usage than Claude.

Makes me think they picked Codex, stopped trying Claude, and just hang on to outdated beliefs about the value they're receiving.

hirvi74today at 9:52 PM

Isn’t that to be expected when comparing one 20x plan to another 5x plan?

I am curious how the 5x plans differ between both providers.

show 1 reply