logoalt Hacker News

bigstrat2003yesterday at 8:41 PM1 replyview on HN

> There is zero question that the Second Amendment was created as limit on the federal government interfering with individual states, and did not bar any state from whatever policy they chose for themselves.

Amendment 10, brought into force at the same time as amendment 2, says that the states can't infringe upon the right to bear arms either. That is very far from "zero question" as you stated.


Replies

Terr_yesterday at 9:24 PM

> Amendment 10 [...] at the same time [...] says that the states can't infringe upon the right to bear arms either.

Uh, no. Just... no. Perhaps you've mixed-up the 10th and 14th, which occurred about a century later.

The 10th does the exact opposite of limiting state power, it says states continue to have all powers they didn't specifically give up by joining. It sets the default for when there's ambiguity, and it sets it in favor of not-the-feds.

> The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.