logoalt Hacker News

merelydev • yesterday at 11:07 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

False dichotomy. Chess/Go can still be played between two humans and there is allot of value in that because humans compare each other to other humans, when you see a skillful Grandmaster play you know they are good compared to yourself or the average human, that is why people still watch, play chess/go and train hard to get good. Programming is different because you are creating something not necessarily trying to win a game.


Replies

redox99 • yesterday at 12:41 PM

Most programming tasks are exactly like that. Is this agent able to complete this task? Is this agent able to optimize a kernel beyond previous attempts?

Of course some are subjective and that's where progress is harder, like "Is this website pretty?". But for tasks that can be objectively measured, LLMs will go beyond human level, just like with Chess and Go.

That's why RL is so important when training LLMs.

➕ show 1 reply
jasondigitized • yesterday at 2:10 PM

Everything is a game