logoalt Hacker News

fasterik • last Sunday at 10:45 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

[flagged]


Replies

mbgerring • last Sunday at 10:50 PM

They literally cannot. They can detect the user’s intent to do math, and then use a different tool to do math, hopefully with the correct inputs. The LLM is not suited to giving deterministic answers to math problems.

➕ show 4 replies
Isamu • last Sunday at 11:03 PM

That is a conflation of LLMs (which have clear limitations) and complex harnesses of which an LLM is one component.

I think it is clear that future AI may incorporate an LLM as a component but the current concept of LLMs are a transitional form that will give way to more capable composite models.

➕ show 1 reply
tjwebbnorfolk • last Sunday at 10:51 PM

They can do math but not arithmetic, which I assume is what the commenter meant

➕ show 2 replies
okanat • yesterday at 12:25 AM

LLMs cannot do math. They can generate tool calls as text that allow them to drive programs and proof agents. Compare and contrast this against human brains who can do math in the same context without needing external tools. We don't need to bring a calculator to count the letters in a sentence. It is a different neural machinery.

➕ show 2 replies