logoalt Hacker News

nevertoolate • yesterday at 6:10 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

It looks like a next token predictor, walks like a next token…

You get my point. It definitely doesn’t look like my elderly neighbour, nor like my daughter, etc. It is confusing but very simple at the same time.


Replies

Kim_Bruning • yesterday at 7:11 AM

Compare grep, sed, and your whole constellation of unix tools that accept characters on stdin and emit them on stdout and stderr; and where you can pipe them together. We can technically call them all 'next character predictors', despite their very different functions.

Don't confuse the stream for the function.

(Bonus: stick ```claude -p``` in your pipe if you want to watch modern tools mesh with traditional)

hardbass • yesterday at 7:57 AM

It looks like a random bunch of inert chemicals to me, doesn't sound like some organic chemicals and electrical signals could result in consciousness.

How are you sure? Another example I like to clarify my thought is, if a "simulation" factors RSA numbers reliably, is it a "simulation"?