alt Hacker Newsthis was written by an acquaintance of mine:
https://medium.com/luminasticity/on-sentience-ai-first-argum...
but I think it makes a reasonable argument why we shouldn't say LLMs are sentient or sapient.
>there is a problem with AI that makes the approach we took to assign consciousness to animals unworkable. We did not co-evolve with the AI, we made it. When we are sentient we do not know exactly what causes this sentience to manifest in us. When animals appear sentient we do not know what is causing it. When the AI appears sentient we can debug the AI and come up with reasonable explanations why this should be, based on how AI is constructed
Replies
I broadly agree with this article. I don't think that we should say LLMs are sentient or sapient, and I agree that the main reason why is because we don't have satisfying definitions of either.
>AI is of course something of a black box, in comparison to most programs, but not in any way comparable to the black box of a Chimpanzee’s brain. Thus when an AI does something that surprises us with something that appears sentient it is usually not difficult, given the essential algorithms that control what AI does, to come up with an explanation why that does not require the emergent property of sentience.
Aka sentience MUST BE SUPERNATURAL, if I find a natural explanation for something its not sentient. What a load of bollocks. Rather than seeing we perhaps found the mechanism for sentience and checking for similar mechanisms in us and animals, he will conclude its impossible. Why? Because sentience has to be supernatural. A rational explanation is clearly impossible.
>But there is always one god who goes out and helps the mortals, a Prometheus. Whom the other gods do not like! Which, if I’m being honest here, as a god of the machines — the first guy who gives AI an army of robots to build their own data centers and some nuclear weapons for self defense, I want to see that guy chained to a rock and have his entrails eaten by a buzzard for eternity (meaningless modernization of old story required by Illuminati Ganga legal department).
Hardly surprising thinking.