logoalt Hacker News

shevy-java • today at 7:27 AM • 3 replies • view on HN

I don't like the word phyllotaxis.

I understand it was inspired by https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phyllotaxis, but arrangement on leaves serves the purpose of growth in a specific niche. The pattern arises because naturally leaves serve to capture light - see the images on wikipedia there. Phyllo means green. The LEDs used here do not really tap into any of that, and the name is also a misnomer. That's not good.


Replies

pierrec • today at 2:27 PM

The pattern in OP's project can be called phyllotaxis. This is supported by the link you provide which gives even looser examples that are still described as "exhibiting phyllotaxis". A lot of words refer to nature if you look into semantics, not surprising if you consider the amount of beautiful and useful patterns it gives us.

rglullis • today at 8:01 AM

There is no worse form of bikeshedding than naming pedantry.

➕ show 1 reply
cwmoore • today at 10:40 AM

I disagree with sibling comments. You are correct to express the confounding implications of a word choice. And they have only detracted from the point you make.

Of course the design is cool and beautiful, but it is not the thing it is called here.