logoalt Hacker News

jameslk • today at 6:49 PM • 5 replies • view on HN

Muse, Dots, and other always-on agents may be the end of the PC era. Once you’re asking agents to do things on their own virtual machines, it’s game over. Everything moves to the cloud

Anyone wondering "why would I use this when I can use (OpenClaw|Hermes|my own computer)" -- these new services are not really meant for you. They're meant for the non-tech savvy and for the next generation of AI-natives who won't know anything other than how to use these type of services

For your casual user, these services will be hard to beat, since they’ll handle all the expensive and hard parts of using computers. No computer purchase necessary, no troubleshooting with tech support, etc. They’re also scalable where you could have not just one agent with one computer at any time, but many

In return, the agent providers would own your compute and data. I can even see them offering this low cost or for free so they can train off of users. Lock in would be insane

For privacy reasons, I really hope we find equally useful, private alternatives on our own hardware


Replies

danscan • today at 7:32 PM

For advanced users, always-on agents that run on your computer where all of your files/apps already are are much more powerful. I think the big AI co's skip this bc it's a smaller market and not as casual

I'm working on an open version that runs agents on your machines and brings a polished UX, and good parallel divide-and-conquer coordination

➕ show 2 replies
kilroy123 • today at 8:55 PM

I don't know... a HUGE amount of people love to game on their PCs.

NickNaraghi • today at 7:45 PM

This makes me surprisingly excited for the iPhone Duo - I didn't like it at first, but seeing it through this lens, seems like Apple is competing for the "AI-native device" of the future.

idontneedcoffee • today at 7:59 PM

Don't you worry, working on it as you sleep(literally given the timezone diff :)

hollowturtle • today at 8:06 PM

> next generation of AI-natives

oh please current generations can't barely use a keyboard

➕ show 1 reply