logoalt Hacker News

pluc • yesterday at 11:05 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

I don't know where you're getting your facts, but according to Fall of Civilizations, it's not just one burnt down building, we're talking of a layer of ash, charred wood and burned material throughout the Eastern Mediterranean.

"The archeological evidence is quite clear: at some point between the year 1200 and the year 1100 BC, right at the end of the period we call the Bronze Age, a wave of destruction washed across the entire region. It wiped whole civilizations off the map and left nothing in its wake."


Replies

db48x • yesterday at 4:20 PM

Yes, that’s the exaggerated tale that everyone knows.

In “Destruction and Its Impact on Ancient Societies at the End of the Bronze Age” <https://www.lockwoodpress.com/product-page/the-fall-of-the-b...> Jesse Millek examines 153 sites claimed to have been destroyed and found that 61% never happened, happened during a different time period, or had a different cause.

Even without buying the whole book you can download the appendix where he summarizes the results. A few notable entries:

Shiqmona: The possibly destroyed public building dates to the fourteenth century BCE. No end of the Late Branze Age destruction was uncovered.

Tell Irbid: C14 dates derived from short-lived samples places the destruction event between 1395–1260 BCE.

Krisa: There is only a statement that the site was destroyed with no published evidence of destruction in any structure.

Iria: Some burnt material in a pit was assumed to be a destruction. There was no damage visible to the buildings.

Athens: The Houses on the North slope were not houses at all. It was refuse that was dumped on the stairs.

Ayios Stephanos: Burning was uncovered in one room from Trench Beta 11. No other damage was recorded.

Amman Airport Structure: Evidence of burning in Room VII can be attributed to the hearth in that room.

Pefkakia: Adrimi-Sismani repeatedly cited a destruction, even though the excavators clearly stated the site was abandoned.

Tell el-‘Ajjul: Bell simply placed it on a map as destroyed with no citations. There was no settlement ca. 1200 BCE.