logoalt Hacker News

jaredhansen • yesterday at 3:56 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

I second this recommendation, with the caveat that it contains a much higher degree of horror than almost anything I've ever read, including accounts of Nazi death camps.

I read that same review a couple of weeks ago and it made a deep impression. It's one thing to know "the Aztecs practiced human sacrifice", and another to be confronted with the scale, sadism and calculation with which it was practiced.


Replies

Lumich • yesterday at 11:23 PM

« accounts of Nazi death camps » — Have you read any that contain actual horrors that you can believe in? If so which ones?

« Aztecs … human sacrifice » — Yes, here, too, the story has been shaped by a certain leyenda negra that Spain's enemies concocted, when in fact the Spaniards set an end to an absurd indigenous slaughter system, allegedly necessary as part of literally everyday life to make the Sun rise every morning.

Humanized sci-fi version would be “Logan's Run” (1967/76), read this reference as “curiously meandering” (dang):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logan's_Run_(film)

cassepipe • yesterday at 5:10 PM

You are right. I should have made that warning. This is not for the faint of heart.

"If anything, the Spaniards lacked the conceptual framework to fully comprehend the industrial-scale, ever-so-civilized and bureaucratic evil of the Mexica, and so they inadvertently downplayed it

[...]

No, the mass-butchery of wailing, pleading captives of both sexes and all ages was the core activity around which their entire civilization and society revolved. Their art, their music, their poetry, their approach to warfare, their entire economic system, their kaleidoscopic array of holidays and festivals, all were singularly dedicated to the killing (often preceded by inventive torture) of helpless human beings"