alt Hacker NewsAbsolutely based. Finally someone of stature in the industry calling this whole fear overblown. Bill Gates sounded like a nontechnical goofball in his Ezra Klein interview where he basically just screamed that the Terminator is real.
There are lots of real worries (government use to suppress the people with minimal manpower or popular support, brainrot and fake news, unemployment due to the belief that LLMs can replace people, education collapse, etc.) we should instead be looking at. This whole rogue AI shtick is tiresome.
Replies
LeCun has been consistently wrong about LLMs though, claiming that they were a dead end and that they'd never be able to do spatial reasoning, which was disproved a year later with GPT-4 [1]. He is also opposed by his fellow Turing laureates Geoffrey Hinton and Yoshua Bengio, who both signed the CAIS statement on AI extinction risk [2].
[1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenAI/comments/1d5ns1z/yann_lecun_...
[2]: safe.ai/statement-on-ai-risk
>Absolutely based. Finally someone of stature in the industry calling this whole fear overblown.
Linus Torvalds was also in the same ballpark with his take on AI, as are the normies on the street using AI on a daily basis.
So it's funny to see the view on AI usage, follow the tech skill bathtub curve.
I watched the same interview, and he and LeCun seem to mostly agree -- both are saying that AI autonomously deciding to kill us isn’t the problem -- it’s what people will do with powerful models that lack safeguards that we should be concerned about.
> Finally someone of stature in the industry calling this whole fear overblown.
Also Andrew Ng 2 weeks ago:
Absolutely based. Finally someone of stature in the industry calling this whole fear overblown.
I'm just as reassured as I was when Edward Teller called the whole fear of his industry overblown.
I think both Gates and Obama said that there's a non-zero possibility of it, but that it's not what they're worried about. And I agree with them. I think the fears are vastly overblown because both OpenAI/Anthropic and the media benefit from the explosive narrative.
>Bill Gates sounded like a nontechnical goofball in his Ezra Klein interview where he basically just screamed that the Terminator is real.
I saw that episode too and he genuinely looked completely out of it, even in terms of his temperament and how he was coming at Klein for putting common questions in front of him, some people are genuinely starting to lose it.
I also found the whole debate about cyber-security and 'rogue' software so bizarre because dangerous malware isn't a new thing, and it's often dangerous not because it's intelligent but just the opposite, because it's tiny, viral and fast. Which describes everything that kills humanity in far larger numbers than anything complex, big and intelligent
Honestly way too much of it rhymes with the old hardcore right wing takes on the "obvious and clear slippery slope" involved with gay rights and the like. How anyone with even some foresight can see how it'll completely erode society as we know it, the worst possible nightmare cases are not just real but imminent unless we change course, yada yada moral panic.
> Bill Gates sounded like a nontechnical goofball in his Ezra Klein interview where he basically just screamed that the Terminator is real.
Did we watch the same interview? Gates all but dismissed the SkyNet scenario as uncertain to be a problem and certainly not a problem on our doorstep. His major concern was catastrophic misuse of AI (e.g., bioterrorism) and economic impact on blue collar workers. Arguably inconsistent with this concern, he also believed it was important to make it available in poorer countries.