logoalt Hacker News

pornel • today at 1:43 AM • 3 replies • view on HN

I don't trust agents writing specs without human approval.

I've been bitten by agent-written ADRs. Agents carelessly add extrapolated details and speculated nice-to-haves that I never asked for, and this becomes a source of bloat that keeps coming back like a boomerang.


Replies

sathish316 • today at 3:24 AM

I’ve found that Agents cannot differentiate between a general principle or abstraction to be followed vs a one-off code review comment that’s applicable only to a single PR.

Lack of this capability makes automated principles or patterns update a recipe for more bloat.

otterley • today at 5:15 AM

Perhaps this is precisely the type of work product that humans should produce instead of LLMs. Humans are the ones making these decisions, after all.

zahrevsky • today at 2:32 AM

Of course I meant you review the docs the agent writes (as well as everything else the agent writes)