logoalt Hacker News

brainwad • yesterday at 12:12 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

This really doesn't match my experience. I can ask an LLM to modify engineering plans using vague natural language prompts and it will find the right place in the plan from the description and then make appropriate modifications, which necessarily requires doing spacial reasoning.


Replies

mym1990 • yesterday at 3:19 PM

Or it’s just taking common examples from training and applying those copied heuristics to your problem? Doesn’t mean it’s actually reasoning about the space and how to solve the problem. It’s the equivalent of a student writing an answer they saw somewhere else without understanding “why”.

➕ show 2 replies
jxcole • yesterday at 3:59 PM

I think the point here is that LeCun was arguing that training on pure text would not grant spatial understanding. I believe most models are trained on spatial data as well, so you are both right.

➕ show 1 reply