logoalt Hacker News

AndrewKemendo • last Sunday at 2:58 PM • 8 replies • view on HN

This looks strikingly similar to my 2017/20 patent:

https://kemendo.com/pdfs/USPatent10757400.pdf

Pretty much all my patents are being infringed at this point.

Lesson to anyone getting patents, they don’t matter unless you have $100M to fight Microsoft or oracle with. At that point might as well just keep your 100M and forget it


Replies

jimrandomh • yesterday at 8:43 PM

Skimming that patent, I see little indication that you solved the actual practical problems with making something like this; you wrote down the problem statement, not the solution. This should not have been granted a patent.

vessenes • yesterday at 12:01 PM

When you file a patent the patent attorneys tell you how critical it is to do so.

When someone infringes a patent, especially if you’re not commercializing your patent, the patent attorneys tell you, “wow, that looks really tough.”

It’s a big company game at this point, in general, or you’d need something that drives an immense amount of value before the patenting seems worth it, as far as I can tell.

➕ show 1 reply
SapporoChris • last Sunday at 8:46 PM

Did you file for a patent in Japan? Foreign countries are not bound by United States patents; U.S. patent rights only apply within the United States.

➕ show 2 replies
FLeXMurphy • yesterday at 3:38 PM

>Pretty much all [...] are being infringed at this point.

So, funny you say that. You know those AI companies that seem to have really good training data...

account42 • yesterday at 3:26 PM

Good. Patents should not reward people for simply being the first to have an idea that others can easily discover independently.

airstrike • yesterday at 12:45 PM

When I wanted to file a patent, the attorneys told me it was only good as my ability to enforce it, which really means how much money I have vs the other guy

intrasight • yesterday at 11:59 AM

I learned that lesson too. But I also learned that you get what you pay for in terms of the patent attorney's skill in crafting claims.

kragen • yesterday at 3:26 PM

They are pretty inarguable prior art for anyone who wants to compete with TDK.