logoalt Hacker News

dom96 • yesterday at 9:55 PM • 5 replies • view on HN

Why aren’t the data centres just honest about their water usage if it’s seemingly so low?


Replies

jerbearito • yesterday at 11:27 PM

Lincoln data center "comes online" in 2026 (info from Google). These are early, non-mature operating numbers. I'm disappointed this wasn't made more clear in the story and, of course, most of the comments here don't understand the context.

flippingheck • yesterday at 10:18 PM

Transparency is not the same thing as honesty.

Companies might want to avoid this being used as a side channel to infer the amount of their compute.

Companies might want to avoid setting a precedent where activists can demand such information.

Companies might want to avoid the effort of publishing this data, or the risk of publishing incorrect data.

tptacek • yesterday at 10:18 PM

I don't understand your question. I'm commenting on the figures we know from this report. I don't have to work out the motives behind them to evaluate whether they're material (they are not).

mhh__ • yesterday at 10:35 PM

Because the marketing teams don't do numbers and it's a high risk strategy

heaney-555 • yesterday at 10:52 PM

They are, and people just accuse them of lying!

Facts & reason do nothing to a moral panic.