logoalt Hacker News

kuerbel • yesterday at 2:47 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

That is not anti solidarity, I know Afternative für Deutschland voters like to frame it this way but it's not.


Replies

sajithdilshan • yesterday at 2:53 PM

Please keep your narrow political views to yourself. Just because someone tells and true fact about hundreds of thousands of Ukrainian refugees that didn’t payed a single Euro into the health insurance system keeps on benefiting from it, doesn’t make them an AfD voter. That’s a sentiment shared by people from every political spectrum in Germany from Linke to AfD.

If you like it or not, it is anti-solidarity if you benefit from a system that you have never contributed. That is just free loading and one should be ashamed of it.

➕ show 3 replies
shevy-java • yesterday at 3:13 PM

That is not an argument though. He gave a specific example.

You brought up only AfD, without giving any counter-example or refuting his arguments. That's now how a discussion should work.

See it from the other side: the argument IS ENTIRELY IRRELEVANT with regards to AfD or any other party. So, an argument should be made from this point of view as well.

➕ show 2 replies
PorciiVorbesc • yesterday at 6:30 PM

[flagged]