logoalt Hacker News

ghm2180 • yesterday at 11:07 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

Yes, SVMs and Random Forests still rule the many worlds of classification problems often not in the spotlight.


Replies

cyber_kinetist • yesterday at 12:21 PM

Support Vector Machines involve solving a large QP optimization problem... which is often done by running a variant of gradient descent (or one of the second- or quasi-second-order optimization algorithms, which involves finding the Hessian as well as the gradient)

➕ show 1 reply
lynndotpy • yesterday at 12:38 PM

Back when I was a researcher, I had a classification problem where the default random forest classifier built into scikitlearn completely dominated the neural method. The best numbers we got were something like a ~30% improvement from baseline for the neural network to ~95% for the random forest.

The disparity was so large that I was certain I must have made a mistake and I spent a few hours debugging, and then a few hours more trying different neural architectures.

Turns out this is just a super common experience for anyone in NNs who would also try the more established learning algorithms.