logoalt Hacker News

vuurmot • today at 1:05 AM • 11 replies • view on HN

GTA 6 is releasing on PS5 right? Who is going to pay a single cent for software if everything can be ripped day 1? Countries with a huge stake in the software industry are going to get crushed?


Replies

Retr0id • today at 1:08 AM

Music and movies can be ripped day 1, and it hasn't done a whole lot.

dgunay • today at 2:02 AM

Piracy is a service problem! If they release a good PC port, I will buy it, as I have done for nearly every other Rockstar game. Hell, if they were to even just automate the port using a similar tool, I wouldn't really mind if the end result were indistinguishable from a decent PC port. I just really don't want to buy a PS5 for a couple exclusives.

dghlsakjg • today at 1:10 AM

Most software and games is available pirated already and has been for decades. You could get pirate games on the original PlayStation two decades ago. Cracking the most recent PlayStation is not going to change things

singpolyma3 • today at 1:21 AM

Everything has always been able to be ripped day 1. People pay for convenience or because it's expected, not because there's no other option

tripleee • today at 1:11 AM

Most games today can be ripped day 1 and they're doing fine. Pirates are a tiny minority

pitched • today at 1:39 AM

Ads can still be served to pirates, especially if they’re product placements baked into the assets shipped.

para_parolu • today at 1:19 AM

Check steam game sales

vuurmot • today at 1:14 AM

I think the replies to my comment are not realistic.

The Goldilocks zone for earning revenue for movies & games were always: Day 1 earnings = Week 1 earnings = Year 1 earnings

The revenue in this case is heavily protected by your IP NOT being copied in a single day, and that people want to experience the product together with their friends.

When people talk about convenience, is there really any inconvenience in downloading a pirated game/movie on release day?

➕ show 1 reply
gchamonlive • today at 1:15 AM

Do people pay only because there's no pirate alternative? Valve showed this with Steam, people pay for convenience and for good service quality. Piracy is an answer to lack of corporate respect about culture and art that's used to create a commercial product, which manifests in enshitification.

xyst • today at 1:22 AM

False, myth. This is a common claim pushed by MPAA/RIAA (the copyright police for music and film industry).

Consumers want _access_ to their games/content. For example, netflix made it easy to "rent" or stream content. But as they slowly clawback those features (multi-streaming, password sharing, incorporate ads, increase prices beyond inflation). Then access to content decreases, visibility decreases.

OptionX • today at 1:12 AM

If you think this project, not even month old, can recompile gta6 to pc and it be in anyway playable on release have I got a bridge to sell you.

➕ show 1 reply