I live in a touristy town that does this with J1 workers. I'll tell you why: The jobs pay $7.25/hour.

The J1s are then packed like sardines into houses where they pay rent by the week. Why by the week? To remind them they're expendable and can be deported at a moment's notice by the restaurant/hotel/amusement park/etc. they work at. The worst I've heard is 16 people living in a 3-bedroom, 1 bathroom house.

The J1s themselves are typically great people. A lot of them do everything they can to stay in the area via Green Cards or whatever. Business that treat their J1s like shit are usually blacklisted by locals, too. We'll actively tell tourists not to give those businesses any business and why.

When you say “I was thinking bout this the other day”, you weren’t thinking about this, in the sense of thinking about skilled worker immigration pathways for technology companies. What you were thinking about appears to be something entirely different - seasonal nonimmigrant unskilled labor.

There’s actually virtually nothing those two things have in common, except some unarticulated sense of grievance that in some unspecified way it would be better if Americans were doing those things.

One summer in my teens I worked as a groundskeeper at a Martha's Vineyard inn, and it _was_ a fun summer. I had a free place to stay (with a friend), plenty of free time, and little adult supervision.

Virtually all the hospitality staff there were European university students. Midway through the summer, they realized that they weren't earning enough to afford their return airfare and they threatened to strike. I don't recall how they resolved the issue, but I believe that they were netting less than minimum wage. Maybe things have changed since then, and maybe not.

The staff at Harris Teeter in Corolla NC (the outer banks) has been nearly 100% young adults from eastern European countries the last few times that I was down there.

I don't know their living situation, but I did see them both walking and riding bikes to the grocery store. It's a somewhat unique situation as the grocery store probably does 90% of their yearly business between June and August each year. I couldn't tell if they all knew each other from home or just from working together.

Do you mean that you are surprised that young Americans aren't working at the boardwalk in the USA or that young Americans are not working at the beaches in Europe?

  s/American/British/
  s/European/Polish/

  s/American/Canadian/
  s/European/Indian/

If you're a non-US citizen, I don't believe it's easy to just switch to a different job, which makes it difficult to just exit out of the job you have. US citizens could leave at any point for another job (or no job) if they chose, putting the staffing at the service roles at risk. Just speculating.

I just went to Asbury Park, NJ about a month ago. It was all local highschool/college kids. I go to an ice cream shop in Brooklyn by a park - all highschoolers.

I think it just depends on the location? But also yes - if I'm worth my salt, why would I take these jobs over higher paying internships? At 19 I was able to land $25/h jobs in tech. Maybe we should rethink the pay scales in terms of sustainability. Unfortunately we live in the US where short term gains are the sole motivator for most companies.

Because you either continue paying rent for the room you're renting the rest of the year, or you risk not having digs in the fall.

For those European workers, a US wage more than pays for the rent for their vacant rent back home.

> who come from Europe for the summer and work in every service industry job imaginable in town

Do they have work visas for this, or are they abusing a travel visa? All the people I knew that did this were doing it illegally.

because the american workers are off working on better opportunities afforded to them because the immigrants are working these service jobs.

And now that there's less of them, the jobs will be replaced by higher wage americans, which will increase inflation from the higher payroll costs.

I actually have taken that job as an American, any questions? I will say the Irish had an amazing work ethic despite being drunk half the time.

some companies (Six Flags) have in the past abused the J-1 summer work travel program, and essentially trap young people in semi-remote dorms for the summer

companies do stuff like this because american young people won't tolerate it

They were taking those jobs, but then the agencies decided they wanted a cut and found cheaper foreign workers, same as always

Wages are always too low if you replace Americans with cheaper foreigners.

Only like 50% US population has a valid passport, 40% are a paycheck away from homelessness, and potential double taxation?

https://rusticpathways.com/blog/how-many-americans-have-a-pa...

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/40-of-americans-one-step-from-p...