alt Hacker NewsThere are many different challenges, each requiring their own solution. I, for one, really miss the old Google Assistant on my Android phone. It would very reliably play most songs that I wanted to hear on Spotify. Gemini fails at this almost every time, and is significantly slower. It's actually a difficult problem, as the songs people want to hear are regularly being released, are often associated with uncommon names, or have words in unusual orders, so normal LLM style tools just don't cut it.
Replies
One of the most common things I did with google assistant was tell it to remind me to do something, and it would reliably create a reminder on my calendar. With Gemini, it is very unreliable. Sometimes it does a google search. Sometimes it just opens a Gemini chat where it parrots back a (sometimes garbled) paraphrase of my request. Etc.
It's also really terrible at recognizing names of my contacts, probably because those names are not represented in the training data.
This reminds me of how the thing iPhones had pre-Siri (so we're talking pre-2010), which was entirely offline, did a better job than even the most modern thing at "Play [one of the finite set of songs in my library]." I sometimes get absurd matches from bands I've never heard of, when the right answer is something right there in my library.