logoalt Hacker News

fifilura • today at 11:30 AM • 10 replies • view on HN

The committee is independent from politics although some dictators may at times misunderstand that.


Replies

belorn • today at 1:01 PM

Where does it say that the Norwegian Nobel Committee is independent from politics?

As stated on their webpage, "As far as possible, the composition of the Committee is to reflect the relative strengths of the political parties in the Storting." - https://www.nobelpeaceprize.org/nobel-committee/

It is independent to the sitting Norwegian government, as members can't have current seats both in the committee and Storting, but several committee do represent the political parties in Norway.

Currently the committee is made from former Leader of the Centre Party, a foreign policy scholar and writer, former Conservative Party cabinet member that was the Minister of Education and Research, a Political scientist and Chief Executive Officer of Utøya AS, and last the former Labour Party Foreign Affairs Secretary.

pczy • today at 12:03 PM

I find it hard to see how the committee can be genuinely independent of politics when its members are appointed by the Norwegian Parliament.

➕ show 1 reply
ks2048 • today at 1:01 PM

"independent from politics" seems to have a few different meanings. One is inherently bad and another is not necessarily bad. Of course the committee is political and the entire nature of the award is political.

kzrdude • today at 11:45 AM

They have really not made the impression that they are independent of politics, all laureates taken together. But if they improve I'm all for it.

➕ show 1 reply
baggachipz • today at 1:17 PM

There's always FIFA to give out a prize if necessary.

➕ show 1 reply
yostrovs • today at 11:59 AM

The committee is selected by the Norwegian parliament, a political body.

➕ show 1 reply
sleepyhead • today at 2:19 PM

It is not really. They claim so but the members are appointed by the Norwegian government. One of the members, Asle Toje, is very much a political appointed member by the right-wing FRP party.

This process is decided by the Alfred Nobel will.

AlexandrB • today at 4:56 PM

They're so independent from politics they gave a Peace Prize to President "Drone Strikes" Obama after he was in office for merely a year.

myth_drannon • today at 2:37 PM

giving the prize to Obama was not political at all.

/s

➕ show 2 replies