logoalt Hacker News

benrutter • today at 3:10 PM • 5 replies • view on HN

Genuine question, is this legal under US anti-monipoly laws?

I don't really know anything about that area, but didn't Facebook get in some trouble for purchasing Instagram in part due to them being competition.

Surely buying a company out only to close their main offering is defined as anti-competitive?


Replies

WorldMaker • today at 3:53 PM

US level anti-trust laws don't touch on a lot of anti-competitive behavior, mostly specifically it almost solely concerns just trusts and monopolies. I don't think I've heard of a court case ever before simply on the death of a product.

But also US anti-trust laws at the federal level have always relied on a strong FCC, FTC, and US Attorney General's Office to execute, all of which are currently neutered and/or understaffed under the current administration (and may take years to recover even in the best case scenarios). The US has decided it is a season for trusts and monopolies.

(See the mergers of Paramount and WB into Skydance consolidating 200+ combined years of movie history into a single monopoly under the Oracle nepobaby and almost directly undoing/mocking one of the largest and oldest anti-trust cases which was US v. Paramount Studios which set precedents for how large a movie studio could grow that lasted almost 100 years.)

(There might be something the state of California could do, but I don't know how much they want to get involved.)

➕ show 2 replies
thayne • today at 3:28 PM

I'm not sure if it is legal or not, but it happens all the time, and nothing is done about it.

IMHO, it shouldn't be allowed.

scottyah • today at 3:59 PM

Do you think Deno was real competition for Cloudflare, and now that they've merged we don't have alternative options for goods/services that are mostly essential?

I think if Cloudflare and Google merged, it still wouldn't be a monopoly because of AWS (and many others).

dml2135 • today at 7:04 PM

> but didn't Facebook get in some trouble for purchasing Instagram

They got scrutiny over it, sure. But trouble? No, I would say that they did not get into trouble.

TSiege • today at 4:28 PM

In what sense did deno compete with cloudflare? It is a niche runtime and cloudflare is a cloud platform

➕ show 1 reply