logoalt Hacker News

cbmuser • today at 4:52 PM • 6 replies • view on HN

Wind and solar power do not provide dispatchable power and they therefore do not replace conventional power plants.

Germany isn't keeping their coal-fired power plants and they're not building new gas-fired power plants despite the energy transition but because of it.

You're spreading conspiracy theories when you claim Katherina Reiche is a fossil fuel puppet. She is doing what has always been the plan for the energy transition: Building gas-fired power plants.

That plan is even in the DENA study for the energy transition:

https://www.dena.de/fileadmin/dena/Dokumente/Pdf/9262_dena-L... (p. 29)

And before you claim DENA is some sort of fossil fuel lobby organization, they're not. DENA belongs to the German state and was founded in 2000 by SPD and Greens:

https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deutsche_Energie-Agentur


Replies

foota • today at 8:03 PM

"Wind and solar power do not provide dispatchable power and they therefore do not replace conventional power plants. Germany isn't keeping their coal-fired power plants and they're not building new gas-fired power plants despite the energy transition but because of it."

4 hour storage battery operated renewables are now cost competitive with gas plants.

➕ show 2 replies
sajithdilshan • today at 9:00 PM

I remember reading somewhere that they are planning on using excessive wind/solar energy to generate Hydrogen gas and use that for energy instead of Hydrocarbon gases.

planb • today at 5:11 PM

Sorry, but in Germany there isn't even much of a debate anymore about whether she is a puppet of the gas industry. She even asked EnBW for arguments in favor of gas-fired power plants in order to avoid holding a technology-neutral tender process as required by the EU: https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/katherina-reiches-minister...

➕ show 1 reply
yangm97 • today at 5:41 PM

Yes, the so called base load isn’t the strength of intermittent renewables and yet Germany turned off clean, nuclear power in favor of gas and coal plants.

I wonder how that happened…

➕ show 3 replies
martin_a • today at 5:55 PM

> conspiracy theories when you claim Katherina Reiche is a fossil fuel puppet

lol, wtf?!

Before becoming a minister she was employed by E.ON (for non-Germans: one of the big four energy companies in Germany) to lobby for their interests.

She is _the_ prototype of a fossil fuel puppet.

cyberax • today at 6:15 PM

> and they're not building new gas-fired power plants

Uh... Whut? They're not just building them, but actively subsidizing them: https://www.cleanenergywire.org/news/german-government-appro...

Because of pinky-promises about 'hydrogen' some time in future.