logoalt Hacker News

MisterMunchkin • yesterday at 4:02 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

A car which tells you when you're about to reverse into the path of another car is safer. I don't really know what to tell you. It's obviously safer.


Replies

hephaes7us • yesterday at 4:19 PM

Sure, but that's a different kind of safety than _crash_ safety.

Plenty of people (rightly or wrongly) are confident in their ability to prevent accidents. Or, at least, confident enough to be skeptical of the tradeoffs involved with these assistive systems.

If I had to choose between a car that has high survivability in a crash versus a car that how worse survivability in a crash but has a few assistive systems that can prevent some crashes (which, mostly, I already prevent by paying attention), I'd choose the former every time.

➕ show 1 reply
swiftcoder • yesterday at 7:26 PM

Yeah, those sensors are great (and, incidentally, even the budget model of the Dacia Sandero has them).

The ones that are less great are the attention sensors they mandated in last-year's models. I test-drove a Kia EV3 a couple of months back, and they've set that sensor up so that even a brief glance at your instrument cluster can ring the attention chime...