logoalt Hacker News

buellerbueller • yesterday at 6:17 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

>Right, this discussion totally isn't being used as a bash Israel/isrealis as inherently bad with lots of blanket statements.

I see lots of (maybe un-carefully-worded, maybe?) bashing of the actions of the current Israeli government, and its defense forces and intel apparatus.

That's 100% fair game, anywhere on the planet.

What's I don't see is the rank antisemitism you claim, except for a few outlier recently-created accounts.

The most despicable thing I see at scale in the conversations is the attempt to silence critics of Israel with slanderous accusations of antisemitism. It used to work, as a tactic, but it (like the "racism card") has been vastly overplayed and is rapidly losing its value.


Replies

_DeadFred_ • yesterday at 7:53 PM

Ah I shouldn't call out what I think is racism because 'it doesn't have impact' anymore. Nah. You think labeling nations /communities and by extension their peoples is fine. I don't. It's simple as that.

I didn't attempt to silence anyone. I simply called out what I see. Silencing is what HN does when they moderate the Ukraine Russian discussions different than their newer standard for Israel Palestine.