logoalt Hacker News

Animats • today at 9:47 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Why? The neural network paper is straightforward and has lots of illustrations showing concrete examples of what happens as images move through the stages of a classifier.

The above quote is from "The world's worst writing".


Replies

lukewarm707 • today at 10:43 PM

Let me quote the opening paragraph of the paper:

"After many months studying neurons and circuits in image and language models, I’ve come to believe a network’s own mechanisms are its legible building blocks, and that the outlook for mechanistic interpretability may be far better than I’d feared. The canonical evidence of polysemanticity and superposition that convinced much of the field, including me, that networks pack concepts arbitrarily was misread. What looked like arbitrary packing was mostly a motif I’ll call recursive generalization, which is much less concerning."

> > "a network’s own mechanisms are its legible building blocks"

Indecipherable.

> > "The canonical evidence of polysemanticity and superposition that convinced much of the field, including me, that networks pack concepts arbitrarily was misread."

State the claim in plain english. Use the active voice.

"Concepts do not overlap arbitrarily."

> > "What looked like arbitrary packing was mostly a motif I’ll call recursive generalization, which is much less concerning."

Jargon!

"Concepts overlap in a recurring pattern."

➕ show 2 replies