logoalt Hacker News

why_at • today at 7:48 AM • 7 replies • view on HN

I just watched this movie tonight and it's one of those where I feel like everyone else saw a different film. For me it was too little butter spread over too much bread. All the interesting parts of the Holmes/Theranos story have been explored, so all that's left is her personal life with her new partner who's also a weirdo.

At best I can say that it makes you think about things like deceit and honesty/accuracy in media, but it definitely didn't blow my mind like it apparently did for this author. After 3 hours I was just exhausted from watching these peoples' tortuous attempts to avoid giving a direct answer to any question.


Replies

gyomu • today at 8:23 AM

> After 3 hours I was just exhausted from watching these peoples' tortuous attempts to avoid giving a direct answer to any question.

I’ve been around a lot of bullshitters my whole life, and my immediate reaction is to go “this person is full of shit, not worthy of my attention, kthxbye”

But I’ve noticed that most people when faced with the same person can’t help but try and figure out what makes them tick, or their redeeming qualities, or if even anything can be redeemed. It seems to be a social equivalent of “nerd sniping”; most people just have a very hard time declaring “this person is worth 0 additional seconds of my time” and actually following through.

See also ppl in toxic relationships, who will complain to their friends incessantly about how bad the other person is and how they know they need to get out of it, only to rarely get out of it.

➕ show 16 replies
a3w • today at 8:42 AM

German nerd here. I know next to nothing about "the interesting parts of the Holmes/Theranos story", is there a documentary on the facts instead of the villain somewhere?

➕ show 8 replies
andsoitis • today at 12:35 PM

> All the interesting parts of the Holmes/Theranos story have been explored

This is similar to the Musk doc. When everything about the person is already explored real-time in the media, there's no mystery left. There's no drama. It is almost as dull as the subject's personality and almost as vacant as the subject's morality. Hmmm, so I guess in a weird self-referential way maybe it is genius? Nah.

treetalker • today at 11:22 AM

> peoples' tortuous attempts to avoid giving a direct answer

In this case, the attempts are simultaneously tortuous, torturous, and tortious!

crispyambulance • today at 1:36 PM

  > After 3 hours I was just exhausted...
I got a feeling that the 4 hour Musk documentary is going to be a similar kind of experience, exploring in extreme detail all the myriad ways that guy is an asshole.