logoalt Hacker News

mejutoco • yesterday at 2:24 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Regex in xml? Now you have 2 problems. And the comments are not xml comments even.

Ultimately it is a dsl. Should equations in math also use full words and comments?

No, they should not. Maybe a nice syntax for grammars like raku is a better approach.


Replies

crazygringo • yesterday at 3:49 PM

I couldn't care less if it looks more like XML or Python or C or whatever. It's just an example.

I just care that things have readable text names rather than inscrutable punctuation and single letters.

Yes, it is a DSL. Just like, you know, Python or C or HTML or CSS. Just because it's a DSL doesn't mean it can't actually use keywords instead of punctuation.

whattheheckheck • yesterday at 7:18 PM

Actually yes? If math equations also wrote a fluent English way of saying the full thing as well as the literal syntax as well every time it would help more people actually understand it.

➕ show 1 reply