logoalt Hacker News

Lex-2008 • yesterday at 5:01 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Agreed. On the other hand, these DV certificates only claim to verify who _controls_ the domain. Probably, you can agree that hosting provider and government can also control the domain, no? :)

Moreover, with dns-01, DNS provider can issue fake certificates - unless you self-host DNS - in which case, only your DNS registrar can... and a government.


Replies

throw0101c • yesterday at 6:41 PM

> Moreover, with dns-01, DNS provider can issue fake certificates - unless you self-host DNS - in which case, only your DNS registrar can... and a government.

Which is what DNSSEC is supposed to help with: the registrar/government would have to replace your DS/KSK with their own. Without DNSSEC queries/replies could potentially be altered over the wire (or you're in a race condition as to whether the real or attacker's reply get back first).