logoalt Hacker News

crote • yesterday at 9:52 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

It wouldn't be immune to MitM on DNS - unless DNSSEC were to become mandatory.


Replies

tptacek • today at 1:19 AM

The problem with this is risk management. In reality, MITM attacks on DV issuance are vanishingly rare --- and close to infeasible in many important cases. But misissuance of DV certs is less rare; it just doesn't happen with MITM attacks. Rather, the usual cause is registrar account takeover.

DNSSEC isn't going to happen, among other things, because it doesn't address a meaningful threat to the WebPKI.

Dylan16807 • yesterday at 9:58 PM

Don't focus too hard on the current method. Just work with me and imagine a value that comes direct from the registry and there's some kind of secure link, maybe DNSSEC maybe not.